Competitive Dynamics in the Political Marketplace: How Donor Firms’ Political Wins Prompt Product-Market Peers to Appoint Politicians to Their Boards
Management Science · 2026 · Zhiyan Wu、Wenjiao Cao
中文摘要
我们利用美国联邦特别选举样本中的断点回归设计,考察捐款企业的政治获胜如何影响其产品市场同行企业在政治活动中的适应性反应,并特别关注同行企业任命政治人物进入董事会的行为。通过分析胜负接近的特别选举,我们发现,当捐款企业曾向以微弱优势赢得特别选举的候选人捐款时,其同行企业在次年任命政治人物进入董事会的可能性,比曾支持以微弱劣势落败候选人的捐款企业的同行企业高出41%。这一适应性反应在面临更高政治风险以及身处政府销售竞争更激烈行业的同行企业中更为明显。捐款企业的政治获胜还会促使同行企业加大与这些捐款企业的产品差异化。我们将这些模式解读为竞争动态机制的证据:同行企业将捐款企业的政治获胜视为一种可能使其在监管环境中处于不利地位的威胁,从而促使其借助政治资本强化董事会,以应对潜在的监管变化并缓解所感知的风险。我们的发现丰富了学界对企业政治活动和董事遴选的理解。本文由 Olav Sorenson(组织)接收。资助:Z. Wu 感谢中国国家社会科学基金 [项目 22&ZD154] 的支持。补充材料:在线附录与数据文件可在 https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2023.02952 获取。
Abstract
Using a regression discontinuity design in a sample of U.S. federal special elections, we investigate how donor firms’ political wins impact the adaptive responses of their product-market peers in their political activities, with a particular focus on the appointment of politicians to their boardrooms. By analyzing closely contested special elections, we find that when donor firms had donated to a candidate who narrowly won a special election, their peer firms were 41% more likely to appoint politicians to their boards in the following year than peers of the donor firms that had supported a narrowly defeated candidate. This adaptive response is more pronounced among peer firms facing greater political risks and operating in industries with more intense competition for government sales. Donor firms’ political wins also lead peer firms to increase their product differentiation from those donor firms. We interpret these patterns as evidence of a competitive-dynamics mechanism, where peer firms perceive donor firms’ political wins as a threat that could disadvantage them in the regulatory environment, prompting them to strengthen their boards with political capital to navigate potential regulatory changes and mitigate perceived risks. Our findings enrich scholarly understandings of corporate political activities and director selections. This paper was accepted by Olav Sorenson, organizations. Funding: Z. Wu acknowledges support from the National Social Science Foundation of China [Grant 22&ZD154]. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2023.02952 .