中文摘要
本研究考察一种普遍存在却鲜有研究关注的知识产权保护形式的使用:商业秘密。在已有关于保密措施在企业层面、横截面上使用的调查证据基础上,我们记录了更强的商业秘密法律保护对项目层面此类秘密使用的影响。我们的研究情境是2014至2018年的美国油气水力压裂行业;在所涉及的各州,企业须向监管机构披露压裂液成分,除非其提出有据可依的商业秘密主张。我们考察2016年联邦《保护商业秘密法》(DTSA)的颁布,如何影响DTSA出台前法律保护水平各不相同的各州在油井层面的商业秘密使用。我们发现商业秘密的使用及其新颖性均大幅提升。此外,使用商业秘密成分的油井平均而言生产率更高。然而,DTSA对与商业秘密相关的生产率仅产生有限的额外影响。补充检验处理了替代性解释,未发现知识产权之间存在替代的证据,并进一步佐证我们所捕捉的确实是政策效应。我们的结果为商业秘密的实际使用提供了罕见的经验证据,并增进了我们对专有性(appropriability)如何塑造商业秘密使用及相关发明活动的理解。本文由创业与创新领域编辑 Toby Stuart 录用。补充材料:在线附录与数据文件可从 https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.01138 获取。
Abstract
This study investigates the use of a prevalent but rarely studied form of intellectual property protection: trade secrecy. Building on existing survey evidence of firm-level, cross-sectional use of secrecy, we document the effect of stronger legal protections for trade secrets on the project-level use of such secrets. Our setting is the U.S. oil and gas hydraulic fracturing industry, from 2014 to 2018, in states where firms are required to disclose fracturing fluid ingredients to regulators except for substantiated claims of trade secrets. We examine how the enactment of the federal 2016 Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA) affects well-level trade secret use across states with varying levels of pre-DTSA protection. We find substantial increases in the use and novelty of trade secrets. Further, wells with trade secret ingredients are, on average, more productive. However, the DTSA exerts limited additional effect on trade secret–related productivity. Supplementary tests address alternative explanations, show no evidence of intellectual property substitution, and provide additional support that we are capturing policy effects. Our results provide rare empirical evidence on actual trade secret use and enhance our understanding of how appropriability shapes use of trade secrets and associated inventive activity. This paper was accepted by Toby Stuart, entrepreneurship and innovation. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.01138 .