Voluntary Minimum Wages: The Local Labor Market Effects of National Retailer Policies
Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2025 · [{"name": "Ellora Derenoncourt", "affiliation": ["Princeton University"]}, {"name": "David Weil", "affiliation": ["Brandeis University"]}]
中文摘要
摘要:几十年来,工会化率低、实际联邦最低工资下降以及外包,阻碍了美国低工资部门的工资增长。近年来(2014—2023年),若干大型私营零售商——其中包括美国部分最大雇主——选择在全公司范围内设立或提高自愿最低工资(VMW)。我们使用一家大型征信机构和一家主要薪资服务提供商提供的匿名薪资数据,研究这些全国性零售商政策对采纳该政策雇主自身工资和就业的影响,以及其对不同界定方式下、共享本地劳动力市场中其他雇主的溢出效应。使用围绕多个VMW事件构建的堆叠事件研究,并采用一个连续处理变量(定义为当地工资与公司最低工资之间的差距),我们发现VMW使实施该政策的公司工资大幅提高,并带来可观的离职率下降。转向其他公司的工资,我们基于对VMW暴露程度的多种度量方式,以及对相关竞争者的多种界定(包括通过工人流动相互关联的企业),估计到的溢出效应普遍较小,且在经济意义上往往可忽略不计。总体而言,证据表明,战略互动在大型零售商工资政策向其他企业传导过程中的作用很小。自愿最低工资政策已影响采纳该政策雇主的300多万个工作岗位,但其对更广泛劳动力市场的影响有限。
Abstract
ABSTRACT Low unionization rates, a falling real federal minimum wage, and outsourcing have hampered wage growth in the low-wage sector in the United States for several decades. In recent years (2014–2023), a number of large private retailers—including some of the largest employers in the United States—have opted to institute or raise company-wide, voluntary minimum wages (VMWs) for their employees. We use anonymized payroll data from a large credit bureau and a major payroll provider to study the effects of these national retailer policies on adopting employers’ own wages and employment as well as their spillovers to other employers in shared local labor markets, variously defined. Using stacked event studies centered around multiple VMW events and a continuous treatment variable defined as the gap between local-area wages and the company minimum, we find that VMWs result in sizable wage increases and reductions in turnover at the companies that implement them. Turning to wages at other companies, we estimate small, often economically negligible, spillover effects across multiple measures of exposure to VMWs and numerous definitions of relevant competitors, including firms connected by worker flows. Together, the evidence points to little role for strategic interactions in the transmission of large retailers’ wage policies to other firms. Voluntary minimum wage policies have affected over 3 million jobs at adopting employers, yet their impact on the broader labor market is limited.