估计医疗保健的代际回报:来自高危新生儿的新证据
Estimating intergenerational returns to medical care: New evidence from at-risk newborns
Journal of Public Economics · 2026 · [{"name": "Damian Clarke", "affiliation": ["IZA - Institute of Labor Economics", "University of Exeter", "Inria Chile", "University of Chile"]}, {"name": "Nicolas Lillo Bustos", "affiliation": ["Ministry of Education", "Ministry of Health"]}, {"name": "Kathya Tapia Schythe", "affiliation": ["University of California, Davis"]}]
中文摘要
我们考察针对高风险新生儿、由政府资助的高强度早期生命干预是否会产生代际传递效应。利用断点回归设计 (RDD) 和智利的行政数据,我们将女性追踪至25岁,记录了一个令人意外的事实:出生时接受处理个体的子女,在下一代出生时的健康指标更差。我们认为这源于选择性生育:边际接受处理的个体生育的可能性显著更高。这些新的典型事实表明,在某些情形下,公共投资在家庭谱系内的长期影响可能与其短期影响大相径庭,从而使必要的强化性干预具有更大权重。
• 高强度新生儿护理降低了死亡率,但产生了负向代际效应。
• 接受处理的母亲生育的可能性高出20%,揭示了一个生育渠道。
• 存在广延边际(生育)与集约边际(健康)的代际回报。
• 负向传递源于选择效应:边际出生个体的健康存量更弱。
• 总体而言,第一代收益显著超过第二代成本。
Abstract
We examine whether intensive early-life government-funded interventions targeted to at-risk newborns are transmitted intergenerationally. Using a regression discontinuity design and administrative data from Chile we follow women up to the age of 25, and document the surprising fact that children of individuals who were treated at birth have worse indicators of health at birth a generation later. We suggest this owes to selective fertility, finding that marginally treated individuals are substantially more likely to give birth. These new stylised facts suggest that in certain circumstances, the long-term implications of public investments within family lineages may be quite different to their short-term implications, placing more weight on necessary reinforcing interventions. • Intensive neonatal care reduces mortality but has negative intergenerational effects. • Treated mothers are 20% more likely to give birth, revealing a fertility channel. • Extensive-margin (fertility) and intensive-margin (health) intergenerational returns exist. • Negative transmission owes to selection: marginal births have weaker health stocks. • First-generation benefits substantially outweigh second-generation costs overall.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →