← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

规模经济之前:美国年轻企业的信息技术战略与绩效动态

Economies Before Scale: I.T. Strategy and Performance Dynamics of Young U.S. Businesses
Management Science · 2025 · Wang Jin、Kristina McElheran

中文摘要

我们考察信息技术(IT)战略的各个维度如何影响年轻企业的绩效,以及其随企业年龄增长而呈现的动态变化。借鉴生命周期理论与企业边界研究,我们推导出基于年龄的绩效差异与IT采购决策之间的关系。我们着重指出一种动态张力:外包在短期内有助于获取前沿投入要素,而所有权则在长期内有利于培育组织专属的资源和能力。利用2006年至2014年人口普查局微观数据构成的大型面板,我们首次提供系统性证据表明,年轻的制造业机构(包括初创企业和现有企业的新设单位)从现代IT外包(ITO)中不成比例地获益。年轻企业尽管面临较高的不确定性、较小的经营规模和较少的互补性组织资本,但仍能从自有的IT资本(ITK)中获得生产率收益。尽管这些回报看似与年长生产者相当,但它们以存活为条件,而存活因ITO而改善,却因ITK积累而受损。将ITK带来的灵活性相关收益与早期ITK投资的年份相关优势相结合,年轻企业被揭示出具有显著高于年长在位企业的IT生产率。一系列大量检验支持因果解释,也支持以缓解不确定性影响为基础的机制(而非规模或成本相关的原因)。这些发现揭示了一种常被忽视的年轻企业活力模式,其与日益数字化时代的经济趋势和管理实践相关。

Abstract

We examine how dimensions of information technology (IT) strategy affect the performance of young businesses, as well as dynamics as they age. Drawing from lifecycle theory and firm boundary research, we derive the relationship between age-based performance differences and IT sourcing decisions. We highlight the dynamic tension between outsourcing’s support for accessing frontier inputs in the short term and ownership’s advantages for developing organization-specific resources and capabilities over time. Leveraging a large panel of Census Bureau microdata from 2006 to 2014, we provide the first systematic evidence that young manufacturing establishments (both startups and new units of existing firms) disproportionately benefit from modern IT outsourcing (ITO). The young also enjoy productivity benefits from owned IT capital (ITK), despite high uncertainty, smaller operational scale, and less complementary organizational capital. Although these returns appear commensurate with those of older producers, they are conditional on survival, which is improved by ITO but harmed by ITK accumulation. Combining flexibility-related gains from ITK with vintage-related advantages in early ITK investment, the young are revealed to have significantly greater IT productivity than older incumbents. A large battery of tests supports a causal interpretation, as well as mechanisms rooted in mitigating the effects of uncertainty (as opposed to size- or cost-related reasons). These findings illuminate an often-overlooked pattern of young-business dynamism relevant to economic trends and management practices in an increasingly digital age.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →