← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

员工董事会代表与资本投资

Employee Board Representation and Capital Investment
Management Science · 2025 · Qinglu Jin、Hui Ma、Thomas M Schmid、Guochang Zhang

中文摘要

我们考察了公司董事会中的对等员工代表制(PER)如何影响企业的资本投资。在德国,PER对国内员工超过2000人的企业具有法律强制性,而对低于这一门槛的企业则不然。利用这一断点,我们发现PER对不同环境中运营的企业具有异质性效应。对于经历正增长的企业,PER提高了其对投资机会的响应度,表明员工参与增强了企业利用增长期权的能力。通过增长期权产生的效应在增长期权价值很高的情况下尤为突出。相反,对于经历负增长的企业,PER降低了投资响应度,表明员工会抵制放弃期权的行使。这一效应在劳动密集度高的企业中更为明显,因为在这些企业中员工可能拥有较强的话语权。此外,经营风险调节了员工代表制的效应——通过增长期权产生的正向效应在高风险企业中被削弱,而通过放弃期权产生的负向效应被加剧,从而表明当业务风险相对较高时,员工董事会代表对追求增长的意愿较低,而在高风险环境中更大力地保护其代表的群体。此外,PER在利用增长期权方面的正向效应被集体谈判协议削弱,而通过放弃期权产生的效应则几乎不受影响。来自股价行为的证据进一步支持了员工代表制影响资本投资的观点。我们的发现对政策制定者以及企业的各类利益相关者都具有相关性。

Abstract

We examine how parity employee representation (PER) on corporate boards affects firms’ capital investments. In Germany, PER is legally mandated for firms with more than 2,000 domestic employees, but not for those below this threshold. Exploiting this discontinuity, we show that PER has heterogeneous effects on firms operating in diverse environments. For firms experiencing positive growth, PER increases their responsiveness to investment opportunities, suggesting that employee participation increases firms’ ability to exploit growth options. The effect through growth options is particularly salient in situations in which growth options are highly valuable. In contrast, for firms experiencing negative growth, PER reduces investment responsiveness, suggesting that employees resist the exercise of abandonment options. This effect is more pronounced in firms with high labor intensity, in which employees are likely to have a strong voice. Furthermore, operational risk moderates the effects of employee representation––the positive effect through growth options is attenuated in high-risk firms and the negative effect through abandonment options is exacerbated, thereby suggesting that employee board representatives are less interested in pursuing growth where businesses are relatively risky, and they protect their constituents more forcefully in high-risk environments. Moreover, the positive effect of PER on exploiting growth options is attenuated by collective bargaining agreements, while its effect through abandonment options is little affected. Evidence from stock price behavior further supports the viewpoint that employee representation affects capital investment. Our findings are relevant to policymakers as well as to firms’ various stakeholders.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →