Misery Needs Company: Contextualizing the Geographic and Temporal Link between Unemployment and Suicide
American Sociological Review · 2024 · Byungkyu Lee、Bernice A. Pescosolido
中文摘要
尽管长期以来的证据表明较高的失业率与自杀率上升相关,但大衰退之后美国出现了一个令人困惑的趋势:即便失业率下降,自杀率仍在持续上升。借鉴社会网络与参照群体理论,我们提出“相同性”概念——此处指个人就业状况与其所在社区中他人境况的一致程度——以阐明失业率如何影响自杀。通过构建2005年至2017年美国自杀死亡的多层数据集,我们发现,虽然失业者相比就业者面临更高的自杀风险,但在地方失业率较高的社区,这一差距会缩小。此外,“相同性”效应不仅存在于地理情境,也延伸至时间维度:全国范围的失业高峰会降低失业者的自杀风险,并削弱地方相同性的重要性。这些发现共同指向一种“情境感知”机制,即地方与全国经济背景塑造了失业的含义,使其解读从个人失败转向系统失败,从而降低其污名。本文为自杀研究中的跨层级交互效应分析提供了新框架,强调了文化作为与社会网络机制深度交织的因素在塑造情境影响中的关键作用。
Abstract
Despite long-standing evidence linking higher unemployment rates to increased suicide rates, a puzzling trend emerged in the United States after the Great Recession: suicide rates continued to rise even as unemployment rates declined. Drawing on theories of social networks and reference groups, we advance the concept of “sameness”—in this case, the extent to which an individual’s employment status aligns with the fate of others in one’s community—to clarify how unemployment rates influence suicide. Constructing a multilevel dataset of U.S. suicide deaths from 2005 to 2017, we find that while unemployed individuals face a higher risk of suicide compared to the employed, this gap diminishes in communities with high local unemployment rates. Moreover, the “sameness” effect extends beyond geographic contexts to temporal ones, as national unemployment spikes reduce suicide risk among the unemployed and diminish the importance of local sameness. Together, these findings suggest a mechanism of “situational awareness,” whereby local and national economic contexts shape the meaning of unemployment, shifting its interpretation from personal failure to system failure and reducing its stigma. Our article offers a novel framework for examining the effects of cross-level interactions in suicide research, highlighting the crucial role of culture as deeply intertwined with social network mechanisms in shaping contextual influence.