← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

课堂中的同伴效应与排名关切

Peer Effects and Rank Concerns in the Classroom
Journal of Political Economy · 2026 · Michela M. Tincani

中文摘要

本文考察学生所处环境的扰动如何传导至其同班同学,以理解课堂同伴互动背后的机制。我将智利的行政数据与调查数据同历史上最强地震之一造成的住房损毁度量相结合。学生自家住房受损降低了其学业成绩,并提高了其自报的学习努力成本。同班同学的平均受损程度促使学校将资源重新配置到学生支持上,并提高了学业成绩。相比之下,同班同学受损程度的离散度对成绩产生了异质性影响,而学校似乎并未对此加以缓解,这指向同伴互动。受学生重视课堂排名这一证据的启发,我表明一个关于成绩竞争的地位博弈模型能够合理解释上述发现。结果表明,除了生产互补性与从众之外,竞争意愿也可能塑造同伴对学习的影响。

Abstract

I examine how disruptions to students’ environments propagate to their classmates to understand mechanisms behind classroom peer interactions. I combine Chilean administrative and survey data with housing-damage measures from one of history’s strongest earthquakes. Damage to a student’s home lowered achievement and raised self-reported study effort cost. Classmates’ average damage induced schools to reallocate resources toward student support and increased achievement. In contrast, dispersion in classmates’ damage had heterogeneous achievement effects that schools did not appear to mitigate, pointing to peer interactions. Motivated by evidence suggesting students value classroom rank, I show that a game-of-status model of grade competition rationalizes the findings. The results suggest that, beyond production complementarities and conformity, a desire to compete could shape peer effects on learning.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →