涉警事件:警察杀人的媒体语言
Officer-Involved: The Media Language of Police Killings
Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2025 · [{"name": "Jonathan Moreno-Medina", "affiliation": ["The University of Texas at San Antonio"]}, {"name": "Aurélie Ouss®", "affiliation": ["National Bureau of Economic Research", "Duke University", "University of Pennsylvania"]}, {"name": "Patrick Bayer®", "affiliation": ["National Bureau of Economic Research", "Duke University"]}, {"name": "Bocar A Ba®", "affiliation": ["National Bureau of Economic Research"]}]
中文摘要
摘要 本文考察美国电视新闻在报道警察致人死亡事件时的语言模式。首先,我们发现,与报道平民致人死亡案件相比,媒体在报道警察致人死亡案件时更常使用模糊责任归属的句法结构——如被动语态、名词化和不及物动词。通过一项在线实验,我们展示了这些句法差异的重要性:当参与者接触到模糊性语言时,他们较不可能认为警察负有道德责任并要求处罚,尤其是在涉及手无寸铁受害者的案件中。对新闻数据的进一步分析显示,当受害者手无寸铁或存在视频画面时——这些情境下模糊化可能产生最大影响——模糊性语言的使用更多。在探究这种差异化模糊化的成因时,我们没有发现证据表明其由需求侧因素、或与电视台所有权及政治倾向相关的供给侧因素所驱动。相反,我们的结果表明,警察部门构建的叙事更可能是媒体模糊化的驱动因素。本文强调了媒体中的句法选择及其语义后果如何塑造公众认知,其影响超越了报道数量和偏向本身。
Abstract
Abstract This article examines language patterns in U.S. television news coverage of police killings. First, we document that the media use syntactic structures—such as passive voice, nominalizations, and intransitive verbs—that obscure responsibility more often in cases of police killings than in cases of civilian killings. Through an online experiment, we demonstrate the significance of these syntactic differences, revealing that participants are less likely to hold police officers morally responsible and demand penalties when exposed to obfuscatory language, particularly in cases involving unarmed victims. Further analysis of news data shows greater use of obfuscatory language when the victims are unarmed or video footage is available—situations in which obfuscation may have the greatest impact. Exploring the causes of this differential obfuscation, we do not find evidence that it is driven by either demand-side factors or supply-side factors associated with TV station ownership and political leaning. Instead, our results suggest that narratives crafted by police departments are more likely drivers of media obfuscation. This article highlights how syntactic choices and their semantic consequences in media shape perceptions, extending beyond coverage volume and bias.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →