← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

财政不透明与选举问责不完善下的债务上限

Debt Ceilings With Fiscal Intransparency and Imperfect Electoral Accountability
International Economic Review · 2025 · Randolph Sloof、Roel M. W. J. Beetsma、Alina Steinweg

中文摘要

我们研究一个政治代理模型中的最优债务上限,模型中同时存在关于政策制定者类型(仁慈型或自利型)与经济状态(好或坏)的不确定性。选举产生约束效应与选择效应,这两种效应在不同上限所引致的混同均衡、混合均衡与分离均衡中各不相同。最优上限在仁慈型政策制定者下扭曲的跨期配置与自利型政策制定者下的过度债务之间进行权衡。在固定上限下,财政透明度提高似乎无效。状态依存型上限通过适应经济状况确实改善了福利。我们的结果支持在改革后的欧盟《稳定与增长公约》中对预算限制加以区分,并凸显了独立财政机构的作用。

Abstract

ABSTRACT We study optimal debt ceilings in a political‐agency model with uncertainty about both policymaker type (benevolent or selfish) and economic state (good or bad). Elections generate disciplining and selection effects that differ across pooling, hybrid, and separating equilibria induced by different ceilings. The optimal ceiling trades off distorted intertemporal allocation under benevolent policymakers against excessive debt under selfish ones. Increased fiscal transparency appears ineffective under constant ceilings. State‐contingent ceilings do improve welfare by adapting to economic conditions. Our results support differentiating budgetary restrictions in the reformed EU Stability and Growth Pact and underscore the role of independent fiscal institutions.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →