← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

家族规则:墨西哥司法系统中的裙带关系

Family Rules: Nepotism in the Mexican Judiciary
Journal of Development Economics · 2025 · Pablo Brassiolo、Ricardo Estrada、Gustavo Fajardo、Juli aacute n Martinez Correa

中文摘要

为保护国家组织免受政治干预,官僚通常被赋予招聘决策的自主权。然而,我们发现,官僚可能利用这种自由裁量权实施损害组织绩效的任人唯亲行为。我们以墨西哥联邦司法系统为背景研究这一现象。平均而言,一名法官到任某一巡回区后,次年内会有0.05名亲属被聘至关键工作人员岗位;使用涵盖职业范围更完整的另一数据集时,这一数字为0.2名。这两项估计都可能是真实效应的下界。这些被聘用的亲属在受教育程度方面往往呈负向选择,且其受聘与法院生产率下降相关,这表明此类任命是由寻租而非效率考量所驱动。值得注意的是,裙带招聘集中于曾因行政违规受到处分的法官,以及被派任至其出生州法院的法官。

Abstract

Bureaucrats are often granted autonomy in hiring decisions to shield state organizations from political interference. However, we show that bureaucrats can exploit such discretion to engage in forms of favoritism that undermine organizational performance. We study this phenomenon in the context of the Mexican federal judiciary. On average, the arrival of a judge at a circuit results in the hiring of 0.05 relatives to key staff positions within the following year, and 0.2 relatives when using an alternative dataset that covers a more complete set of occupations. Both estimates are likely to represent lower-bounds of the true effect. These related hires tend to be negatively selected in terms of educational attainment and are associated with a decline in court productivity, suggesting that appointments are driven by rent-seeking rather than efficiency considerations. Notably, nepotistic hiring is concentrated among judges who have been sanctioned for administrative offenses and those assigned to courts located in their state of birth.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →