The Impact of Online Competition on Local Newspapers: Evidence from the Introduction of Craigslist
Review of Economic Studies · 2024 · Milena Djourelova、Ruben Durante、Gregory Martin
中文摘要
来自在线平台的竞争如何影响报纸的组织方式、绩效表现和编辑选择?这些变化对选民接触到的信息及其政治选择又有何影响?我们利用全球最大的在线分类广告平台 Craigslist(CL)在 1995 年至 2009 年间于美国各县交错(分批)推出这一情境来研究上述问题。这一设定使我们能够将分类广告竞争的影响与互联网带来的其他变化区分开来, 并比较事前对分类广告依赖程度较高与较低的报纸。我们发现, 在 CL 进入后, 依赖分类广告的地方报纸在管理和新闻编辑室员工数量上出现显著下降, 其中包括负责政治报道的编辑人数减少。这些组织变化导致政治新闻报道减少, 并造成报纸读者数量下降, 尤其是在政治兴趣较高的读者中。最后, 我们记录到, 地方政治新闻接触的减少与党派投票增加、以及国会选举中意识形态极端候选人的参选和胜选增加相关。总体而言, 我们的发现揭示了印刷媒体衰落的决定因素, 以及其对民主政治更广泛的影响。
Abstract
Abstract How does competition from online platforms affect the organization, performance, and editorial choices of newspapers? What are the implications of these changes for the information voters are exposed to and for their political choices? We study these questions using the staggered introduction of Craigslist (CL)—the world’s largest online platform for classified advertising—across U.S. counties between 1995 and 2009. This setting allows us to separate the effect of competition for classified advertising from other changes brought about by the Internet, and to compare newspapers that relied more or less heavily on classified ads ex ante. We find that, following the entry of CL, local newspapers reliant on classified ads experienced a significant decline in the number of management and newsroom staff, including in the number of editors covering politics. These organizational changes led to a reduction in news coverage of politics and resulted in a decline in newspaper readership, particularly among readers with high political interest. Finally, we document that reduced exposure to local political news was associated with an increase in partisan voting and increased entry and success of ideologically extreme candidates in congressional elections. Taken together, our findings shed light on the determinants of the decline of print media and on its broader implications for democratic politics.