扩大儿童早期项目规模的经济学:来自芝加哥学校的教训
The Economics of Scaling Early Childhood Programs: Lessons from the Chicago School
Journal of Political Economy · 2025 · [{"name": "John A. List", "affiliation": []}]
中文摘要
许多想法在小规模试验中取得成功,但在推广至更大规模后效果显著减弱。本文以儿童早期投资为案例,构建了一个具有芝加哥学派风格的动态微观基础人力资本模型。该框架包含优化主体、互补性技能形成机制,以及负责选择规模化策略的政策制定者。模型表明,基于试点项目的朴素外推会因忽视“电压降”——即由于样本与情境缺乏代表性而导致收益-成本状况不断下降——而系统性地高估社会影响。最优规模化需要“选项C思维”——一种基于机制设计的方法,通过从现实世界的实施约束出发进行逆向归纳,来预判此类失败。本专刊收录的研究进一步丰富了该模型的洞见。
Abstract
Many ideas succeed in small trials but weaken considerably at scale. Using early childhood investment as a case study, this paper develops a dynamic microfounded human capital model stylized in the Chicago tradition. The framework features optimizing agents, complementary skill formation, and a policymaker choosing scaling strategies. The model shows that naive extrapolation from pilots systematically overestimates societal impact by overlooking voltage drops: declining benefit-cost profiles due to unrepresentative samples and contexts. Optimal scaling requires option C thinking, a mechanism-based design approach that anticipates these failures through backward induction from real-world implementation constraints. Studies in this special issue enrich the model’s insights.
📖 精读解析
本文已有三模型交叉精读卡片, 登录后可在站内查看结构化解读与关键图表。
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →