Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2025 · Christine L. Exley、Oliver Hauser、Molly Moore、John-Henry Pezzuto
中文摘要
尽管关于社会偏好性别差异的文献十分丰富(但结论不一),学界对人们所认为的社会偏好性别差异却知之甚少。利用来自15项研究、8,979名个体的数据,我们发现人们认为女性比男性更慷慨、更注重平等。这种被认为存在的性别差距在战略考量、自利动机、公平概念和收益等方面各不相同的广泛情境中均具有稳健性。然而,这种被认为存在的性别差距在很大程度上并不准确。与联想记忆模型——特别是相似性和干扰的作用——相一致,这种被认为存在的性别差距与从相似情境中回忆起的既往生活经历相关,并显著受到一种可能干扰既往记忆回忆过程的经历的影响,尽管这种干扰性经历本不应影响拥有完美记忆的贝叶斯人的信念。应用研究进一步表明,这种被认为存在的性别差异延伸至家庭领域(即关于对家庭事务、家人以及子女养育贡献的信念)、工作场所(即关于同工同酬的信念)和政策观点(即关于再分配、平等获得教育、医疗保健和经济适用房的信念)。
Abstract
Abstract While there is a vast (and mixed) literature on gender differences in social preferences, little is known about believed gender differences in social preferences. Using data from 15 studies and 8,979 individuals, we find that women are believed to be more generous and more equality-oriented than men. This believed gender gap is robust across a wide range of contexts that vary in terms of strategic considerations, selfish motives, fairness concepts, and payoffs. Yet this believed gender gap is largely inaccurate. Consistent with models of associative memory, specifically the role of similarity and interference, the believed gender gap is correlated with recalled prior life experiences from similar contexts and significantly affected by an experience that may interfere with the recall process of prior memories, even though this interfering experience should not affect the beliefs of perfect-memory Bayesians. Application studies further reveal that believed gender differences extend to the household (i.e., beliefs about contributions to the home, family, and upbringing of children), the workplace (i.e., beliefs about equal pay), and policy views (i.e., beliefs about redistribution, equal access to education, healthcare, and affordable housing).