当保护变成剥削:解雇成本对天真员工的影响
When protection becomes exploitation: The impact of firing costs on Naïve Employees
Journal of Public Economics · 2026 · [{"name": "Florian Englmaier", "affiliation": []}, {"name": "Matthias Fahn", "affiliation": ["Ifo Institute for Economic Research", "IZA - Institute of Labor Economics", "University of Hong Kong"]}, {"name": "Ulrich Glogowsky", "affiliation": ["Johannes Kepler University of Linz", "Ifo Institute for Economic Research"]}, {"name": "Marco A. Schwarz", "affiliation": ["Ifo Institute for Economic Research", "Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf"]}]
中文摘要
本文识别出就业保护法可能损害劳动者的一条新渠道:它使雇主能够剥削天真的、具有现时偏误的员工。解雇成本使剥削成为可能的理论机制,建立在一种普遍存在的职业结构之上。雇主经常提供这样的职业轨迹:入职阶段缺乏吸引力(例如低薪或高强度工作),职业中期阶段吸引力更低,而在最终阶段承诺给予高回报。天真的员工接受此类合同,期望能够完成这条高回报路径。然而,当成本变得凸显、而回报仍然遥远时,他们最终会在职业中期退出或分流至其他路径。结果,雇主得以避免支付承诺的回报,同时攫取职业早期阶段产生的剩余。解雇成本使雇主拥有更大空间以此类合同剥削员工:它们降低了员工预期的被解雇风险,并使长期回报显得更加可信。于是,雇主可以进一步剥削员工——例如通过降低职业早期工资——因为他们知道,员工即便最终不会坚持到底,仍会接受这种更陡峭的合同。我们的模型与医疗、学术界或会计等领域的职业模式相一致。该模型还就工资结构、员工流失,以及解雇成本与劳动力市场状况如何塑造合同设计,提出了一系列可检验的预测。
Abstract
This paper identifies a new channel through which employment protection laws can harm workers: they enable employers to exploit naïve present-biased employees. The theoretical mechanism through which firing costs enable exploitation is built upon a widespread career structure. Employers frequently offer career trajectories with an unattractive entry phase (e.g., with low pay or high effort), an even less attractive mid-career stage, and high rewards promised in a final career phase. Naïve employees accept such contracts, expecting to complete the high-reward track. They, however, eventually drop out or sort into alternative paths mid-career when costs loom large and rewards remain distant. As a result, employers avoid paying the promised rewards while capturing surplus from early-career phases. Firing costs give employers more leeway to exploit workers with such contracts: they reduce the employees’ expected risk of dismissal and make long-term rewards appear more credible. Employers can then exploit employees even more—for example, by lowering early-career wages—knowing that employees will still accept such steeper contracts despite not following through. Our model aligns with career patterns in fields such as healthcare, academia, or accounting. It also yields testable predictions on wage structures, attrition, and how firing costs and labor market conditions shape contract design.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →