← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

社会信号与儿童免疫接种:塞拉利昂的一项田野实验

Social Signaling and Childhood Immunization: A Field Experiment in Sierra Leone
Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2024 · [{"name": "Anne Karing", "affiliation": ["University of Chicago"]}]

中文摘要

本文探讨将社会信号作为一种政策工具,以可持续地影响儿童免疫接种。在塞拉利昂与公立诊所合作开展的一项为期26个月的田野实验中,笔者引入了一种可验证信号——以颜色编码手环的形式——在儿童按时完成前四剂或全部五剂规定疫苗接种时发放。信号提高了父母对其行为可见性的信念,以及对其他儿童疫苗接种状态的了解。信号的影响随该行为的成本和感知收益而显著变化:当信号与一种较易完成且感知收益较低的疫苗相关联时,对按时和完整免疫接种没有可辨别影响;而当信号与一种实现成本更高且感知收益较高的疫苗相关联时,则产生较大的正向影响。父母在实现社会形象收益前九个月就已调整其行为,表明信号激励具有较强的动机作用。就实质性政策意义而言,手环使一岁时完成全程免疫接种的比例提高9个百分点,且影响持续至两岁。按每名完成全程免疫接种儿童24.7美元的边际成本计算,社会信号的成本效益可与现金或实物激励相当。

Abstract

This article explores the use of social signaling as a policy tool to sustainably affect childhood immunization. In a 26-month field experiment with public clinics in Sierra Leone, I introduce a verifiable signal-in the form of color-coded bracelets-given to children upon timely completion of the first four or all five required vaccinations. Signals increase parents' belief in the visibility of their actions and knowledge of other children's vaccine status. The impact of signals varies significantly with the cost and perceived benefits of the action. There are no discernible effects on timely and complete immunization when the signal is linked to an easier-to-complete vaccine with low perceived benefits, and large positive effects when the signal is linked to a costlier-to-achieve vaccine with high perceived benefits. Parents adjust their behavior nine months before realizing the social image benefit, demonstrating the motivational strength of signaling incentives. Of substantive policy importance, bracelets increase full immunization at one year of age by 9 percentage points, with impacts persisting at two years of age. At a marginal cost of US$24.7 per fully immunized child, social signals can be as cost-effective as financial or in-kind incentives.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →