← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

1789年后的法国:评埃尔斯特《1789年前的法国》

France after 1789: Essay on Elster’s France before 1789
Journal of Economic Literature · 2024 · Antoine Parent

中文摘要

在这篇评述埃尔斯特(2020)著作的文章中,我表达了对行为分析工具能否正确处理君主专制政体与法国大革命所遗留的民主制度之间的过渡阶段的担忧。我重新肯定了那个时代的政治哲学家基内、德·萨德和勒鲁那些被遗忘的分析,恢复其应有价值,并主张:正确理解法国大革命的本质,关键在于其政治哲学维度,而非其参与者所谓的心理特征。我提出一种重新理解革命并对其建模的方式,将政治哲学、宏观经济动态和复杂性经济学三个分析层面结合起来。

Abstract

In this essay on Elster’s (2020) book, I expose my concerns about the ability of behavioral tools to correctly address the transition phase between the absolutist regime and the democratic institutions inherited from the French Revolution. Rehabilitating the forgotten analyses of contemporary political philosophers Quinet, de Sade, and Leroux, I defend the view that a correct understanding of the French Revolution’s essence lies in its political philosophical dimension, not in the supposed psychological traits of its actors. I suggest a renewed way to apprehend and model revolutions, combining three levels of analysis: political philosophy, macroeconomic dynamics, and complexity economics. (JEL D72, D74, N13, N43, Z13)
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →