Cognitive versus Physical Impairment and the Use and Cost of Long-Term Care in Japan
中文摘要
日本拥有全球老龄化程度最高的人口和全民长期照护保险(LTCI)制度,但认知障碍与身体功能障碍在照护使用和成本方面有何差异,仍缺乏充分研究。我们使用具有全国代表性的《国民生活基础调查》数据(2016年和2019年两轮调查;324,466名65岁及以上成年人),比较三类群体的长期照护利用、强度和成本:被诊断为痴呆症者(定义为定期接受痴呆症医疗治疗者)、存在身体功能(日常生活活动能力,ADL)受限但无痴呆症者,以及二者均无者。痴呆症诊断与照护使用的大幅增加相关——75.3%的痴呆症患者接受某种照护,而无障碍参照组这一比例为5.3%。在调整人口和社会经济特征的模型中,痴呆症使接受正式照护的概率提高55个百分点,使接受非正式照护的概率提高52个百分点——约为ADL受限影响的两倍;并且在使用照护的条件下,痴呆症与每月约增加113小时的正式照护相关(比仅有身体功能受限者约高60%)。我们估计,正式照护成本占GDP的1.07%–4.03%(取决于估值方法),同住家庭成员提供的非正式照护成本占GDP的0.79%。痴呆症患者的人均正式照护成本显著更高(采用自我报告法计算,年均约350万日元,而身体功能受限者约为200万日元),但不同障碍类型的非正式照护成本几乎相同——这凸显了家庭照护者所作出的高强度且在很大程度上不可见的贡献。预计到2040年,痴呆症和轻度认知障碍人口将达到约1,200万;这些发现表明,认知障碍将给日本带来越来越大的财政和家庭照护压力。
Abstract
Japan has the world’s oldest population and a universal Long-Term Care Insurance (LTCI) system, yet how care use and costs differ between cognitive and physical impairment remains underexamined. Using the nationally representative Comprehensive Survey of Living Conditions (2016 and 2019 waves; 324,466 adults aged 65 and older), we compare the utilization, intensity, and cost of long-term care across three groups: those with a dementia diagnosis (defined as regularly receiving medical treatment for dementia), those with physical (ADL) limitations but no dementia, and those with neither. A dementia diagnosis is associated with dramatically higher care use—75.3% receive some care, versus 5.3% of the unimpaired reference group. In models adjusting for demographic and socioeconomic characteristics, dementia raises the probability of receiving formal care by 55 percentage points and informal care by 52 percentage points—roughly double the effects of ADL limitations—and, conditional on use, is associated with about 113 additional hours of formal care per month (some 60% more than physical limitations alone). We estimate formal-care costs at 1.07–4.03% of GDP (depending on the valuation method) and co-residing informal-care costs at 0.79% of GDP. Per-capita formal-care costs are substantially higher for those with dementia (about 3.5 versus 2.0 million JPY annually under the self-reported approach), whereas informal-care costs are nearly uniform across impairment types—underscoring the intensive, and largely invisible, contribution of family caregivers. With the dementia and mild-cognitive-impairment population projected to reach roughly 12 million by 2040, these findings point to mounting fiscal and family-care pressures from cognitive impairment in Japan.