Economic Consequences of Kinship: Evidence From U.S. Bans on Cousin Marriage
Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2023 · Arkadev Ghosh、Sam Il Myoung Hwang、Munir Squires
中文摘要
近亲婚姻通过维系紧密的家族结构,可能阻碍发展。我们利用美国各州的堂表亲婚姻禁令,找到了支持这一假说的证据。我们利用同姓婚姻的超额频率衡量堂表亲婚姻,这一方法借鉴自群体遗传学,我们将其应用于18至20世纪的数百万条婚姻记录。利用人口普查数据,我们首先发现,与堂表亲结婚的人更倾向于居住在农村地区,且所从事职业的薪酬较低。随后,我们采用事件研究分析,考察堂表亲婚姻禁令如何影响受禁令影响的出生队列的结果。我们发现,这些禁令使来自堂表亲婚姻发生率较高家庭的个体迁离农场,进入城市地区。他们还逐渐转向薪酬较高的职业。我们观察到分散程度上升:来自这些家庭的个体居住地分布更广,所从事的职业也更加多样。我们的研究结果提示,这些变化是由分散的家族关系所带来的社会与文化效应驱动的,而非遗传因素。值得注意的是,这些禁令还使更多人居住在为老年人、病弱者或赤贫者设立的机构中,这提示来自亲属的支持有所减弱。
Abstract
Abstract Close-kin marriage, by sustaining tightly knit family structures, may impede development. We find support for this hypothesis using U.S. state bans on cousin marriage. Our measure of cousin marriage comes from the excess frequency of same-surname marriages, a method borrowed from population genetics that we apply to millions of marriage records from the eighteenth to the twentieth century. Using census data, we first show that married cousins are more rural and have lower-paying occupations. We then turn to an event study analysis to understand how cousin marriage bans affected outcomes for treated birth cohorts. We find that these bans led individuals from families with high rates of cousin marriage to migrate off farms and into urban areas. They also gradually shift to higher-paying occupations. We observe increased dispersion, with individuals from these families living in a wider range of locations and adopting more diverse occupations. Our findings suggest that these changes were driven by the social and cultural effects of dispersed family ties rather than genetics. Notably, the bans also caused more people to live in institutional settings for the elderly, infirm, or destitute, suggesting weaker support from kin.