← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

质量信号与可再生能源技术需求:来自随机实地试验的证据

Quality signaling and demand for renewable energy technology: Evidence from a randomized field experiment
Journal of Development Economics · 2025 · Aidan Coville、Joshua Graff Zivin、Arndt Reichert、Ann‐Kristin Reitmann

中文摘要

太阳能技术具有私人回报与社会回报,但由于市场对高质量产品的需求持续低迷,其技术潜力往往未能实现。我们在塞内加尔开展了一项随机实地试验,评估三类质量信号提升高质量太阳能灯需求的潜力。研究发现,向消费者提供退款保证对需求没有影响,但第三方认证或保修则会增加需求,这与消费者对产品耐用性(而非其效用)存在不确定性的观点相符。然而,尽管支付意愿有所提高,就普通家庭而言,其愿意支付的价格仍远低于市场价格,这表明仅减少信息不对称不足以促进更广泛的采用。令人意外的是,我们还发现,在本研究情境下,有效的质量信号会在对该产品最不熟悉的人群中产生产品类别效应,从而反而刺激了对低质量产品的需求。• 质量信号有潜力增加离网太阳能技术的需求。• 退款保证对高质量太阳能灯的需求没有影响。• 第三方认证和两年保修使支付意愿提高12%–14%。• 有效的质量信号也会刺激对未经认证的低质量产品的需求。

Abstract

Solar technologies have been associated with private and social returns, but their technological potential often remains unachieved because of persistently low demand for high-quality products. In a randomized field experiment in Senegal, we assess the potential of three types of quality signaling to increase demand for high-quality solar lamps. We find no effect on demand when consumers are offered a money-back guarantee but increased demand with a third-party certification or warranty, consistent with the notion that consumers are uncertain about product durability rather than their utility. However, despite the higher willingness to pay, the prices they would pay are still well below market prices for the average household, suggesting that reducing information asymmetries alone is insufficient to encourage wider adoption. Surprisingly, we also find that the effective quality signals in our setting stimulate demand for low-quality products by creating product-class effects among those least familiar with the product. • Quality signals have the potential to increase demand for off-grid solar technology. • Money-back guarantee has no effect on the demand for high-quality solar lamp. • Third-party certification and 2-year warranty increase willingness to pay by 12–14 %. • Effective quality signals also stimulate demand for uncertified low-quality product.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →