← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

劳动法规合规执法与企业结果:来自巴西的证据

Enforcing compliance with labor regulations and firm outcomes: Evidence from Brazil
Journal of Development Economics · 2025 · Thaline do Prado、Marcelo Rodrigues Santos、Bernardus Van Doornik

中文摘要

在发展中经济体,许多正规企业以非正规方式雇用部分劳动力,以规避严格劳动法规带来的成本。劳动监察是确保合规、促进劳动力市场更具竞争性的重要政策工具,但也可能对企业结果产生非预期后果。本文使用一套独特的行政数据,包括劳动监察信息、雇主—雇员匹配数据(RAIS)以及巴西中央银行的信贷登记数据,就巴西受到严格监管的劳动力市场中企业接受监察后的动态提供了新的研究发现。采用双重差分方法,我们观察到正规就业大幅增加,而营业收入并未立即受到影响,这表明受监察企业往往会在监察后将未登记员工正规化。然而,我们的结果还显示,从长期来看,监察对企业绩效产生了较大的负向影响,并提高了企业退出的可能性,说明受稽查企业难以抵消正规用工成本。此外,我们发现,受监察企业面临更为紧缩的信贷条件,凸显了劳动法规执法所产生的更广泛经济影响。通过考察不同市镇之间的异质性,我们发现,监察的不利影响在非正规就业率较低的地区更为明显。总而言之,本研究填补了关于劳动法执法如何影响企业动态的认识空白,并为理解企业在监管严格的环境中面临的权衡取舍提供了启示。

Abstract

In developing economies, many formal firms hire a portion of their workforce informally to bypass the costs of stringent labor regulations. While labor inspections serve as an important policy tool to ensure compliance, promoting a more competitive labor market, they may also have unintended consequences on firms’ outcomes. Using a unique set of administrative data that includes information on labor inspections, matched employer–employee data (RAIS), and credit registry data from the Central Bank of Brazil, this paper provides novel findings on post-inspection dynamics at the firm level within Brazil’s heavily regulated labor market. Employing a difference-in-differences approach, we observe a surge in formal employment without any immediate impact on revenue, suggesting that inspected firms tend to formalize their unregistered workers after an inspection. However, our results also reveal a large negative impact on firm performance and an increased likelihood of exit in the long run, indicating that audited firms struggle to offset the costs of formal labor. In addition, we find that inspected firms face tighter credit conditions, emphasizing the broader economic implications of enforcing labor regulations. By exploring heterogeneity across municipalities, we discern that the adverse effects of inspections are more pronounced in areas with lower informality rates. All in all, this research fills a gap in understanding how labor law enforcement affects firm dynamics, offering insights into the trade-offs faced by firms in heavily regulated environments.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →