← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

产业政策的教科书式依据:理论与数据的碰撞

The Textbook Case for Industrial Policy: Theory Meets Data
Journal of Political Economy · 2024 · Dominick Bartelme、Arnaud Costinot、Dave Donaldson、Andrés Rodrı́guez-Clare

中文摘要

产业政策的教科书式依据已广为人知:具有相对较大外部规模经济的部门应获得补贴,而以其他部门为代价。然而,人们对此类干预所带来的福利收益量级知之甚少。我们提出一种实证策略,利用普遍可得的贸易数据估计部门层面的规模经济,进而在一般均衡环境中量化最优产业政策的收益。我们的结果表明,制造业各部门存在显著的规模经济,但产业政策带来的收益即便在开放程度最高的经济体中也几乎不具变革性。

Abstract

The textbook case for industrial policy is well understood: sectors with relatively large external economies of scale should be subsidized at the expense of other sectors. Little is known, however, about the magnitude of the welfare gains from such interventions. We develop an empirical strategy that leverages commonly available trade data to estimate sector-level economies of scale and, in turn, to quantify the gains from optimal industrial policy in a general equilibrium environment. Our results point toward significant economies of scale across manufacturing sectors but gains from industrial policy that are hardly transformative, even among the most open economies.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →