← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

青少年犯罪与预期惩罚

Juvenile Crime and Anticipated Punishment
American Economic Journal: Economic Policy · 2023 · Ashna Arora

中文摘要

制裁能否威慑青少年犯罪?研究表明,制裁可能无法起到威慑作用,因为当个体跨过刑事成年年龄、开始面临更严厉的制裁时,违法行为几乎没有减少。然而,多种犯罪行为模型预测,门槛附近的这些微弱反应可能掩盖了年龄门槛以下个体更大的行为反应。本文利用美国2007—2015年间的政策变动,提供了与这些预测一致的证据——提高刑事成年年龄会导致青少年犯罪增加。这一增幅由年龄较小的群体所驱动,且远大于门槛处的断点回归估计值。(JEL D91、J13、K42)

Abstract

Can sanctions deter juvenile crime? Research indicates that they may not, as offending barely decreases when individuals cross the age of criminal majority and begin to face harsher sanctions. Several models of criminal behavior predict, however, that these small reactions close to the threshold may mask larger behavioral responses among individuals below the age threshold. Policy variation between 2007–2015 in the United States is used to show evidence consistent with these predictions—juvenile crime increases when the age of majority is increased. This increase is driven by younger age groups and is considerably larger than discontinuity estimates at the threshold. (JEL D91, J13, K42)
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →