← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

好运得令人难以置信:作弊阴影下的公平观

Too Lucky to Be True: Fairness Views under the Shadow of Cheating
Review of Economics and Statistics · 2023 · Stefania Bortolotti、Ivan Soraperra、Matthias Sutter、Claudia Zoller

中文摘要

社会内部的收入不平等往往伴随着这样的证据:富人更可能行为不端,并逃避更多税款。我们研究当作弊可能是、但未必是收入不平等的成因时,公平观与再分配偏好会受到怎样的影响。在实验中,我们让第三方在一名富裕利益相关者和一名贫困利益相关者之间重新分配收入。在一个处理组中,收入不平等仅由运气造成;而在另外两个处理组中,富裕利益相关者可能存在作弊行为。仅仅是对作弊的怀疑,就会显著改变第三方的公平观,并导致强烈的两极分化;当作弊产生负外部性时,这种两极分化更为明显。

Abstract

Abstract Income inequalities within societies are often associated with evidence that the rich are more likely to behave unethically and evade more taxes. We study how fairness views and preferences for redistribution are affected when cheating may, but need not, be the cause of income inequalities. In our experiment, we let third parties redistribute income between a rich and a poor stakeholder. In one treatment, income inequality was due only to luck, whereas in two others rich stakeholders might have cheated. The mere suspicion of cheating changes third parties’ fairness views considerably and leads to a strong polarization that is even more pronounced when cheating generates negative externalities.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →