← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

溢出实验中的稳健信号最大化

Robust Signal Maximization in Spillover Experiments
NBER Working Papers · 2026 · Kirill Borusyak、Peter Hull、Evan M. Munro

中文摘要

我们研究了用于估计溢出效应的实验的最优设计与分析。假设已知(例如线性的)暴露映射,我们刻画了处理分配分布与基于回归的估计量,它们在一类广泛的不可观测变量分布下,最小化了最差情形渐近方差。设计问题产生了一个直观的解,其中规划者在溢出信号强度与溢出变异的扩散之间进行权衡。分析问题产生了一个简单的重新中心化的工具变量估计量,以最佳地利用这一变异。该框架在几个基准情形中给出了自然的解——例如聚类暴露——并为一般网络(包括二分图设定)提出了计算上可行的近似。我们在基于发展经济学两项应用的半合成实验中说明了这些新工具。我们的方法在两个实验中均大幅降低了标准误,使有效样本量增加了50–100%或更多。

Abstract

We study the optimal design and analysis of experiments for estimating spillover effects. Assuming a known (e.g., linear) exposure mapping, we characterize the treatment-assignment distribution and regression-based estimator that minimize worst-case asymptotic variance against a broad class of distributions of unobservables. The design problem yields an intuitive solution in which the planner trades off spillover signal strength against diffusion of spillover variation. The analysis problem yields a simple recentered instrumental variable estimator to best leverage this variation. This framework produces natural solutions in several benchmark cases -- such as clustered exposure-- and suggests computationally tractable approximations for general networks, including bipartite settings. We illustrate these new tools in semi-synthetic experiments based on two applications from development economics. Our approach yields large standard error reductions in both experiments, increasing effective sample sizes by 50–100% or more.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →