← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

煽动性政治竞选活动与警务执法中的种族偏见

Inflammatory Political Campaigns and Racial Bias in Policing
Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2022 · Pauline Grosjean、Federico Masera、Hasin Yousaf

中文摘要

政治集会能否影响执法人员对待少数族裔的行为?利用3500万次交通拦截的数据,我们发现,在特朗普2015—2016年竞选期间举行的一场集会后,被拦截驾驶员为黑人的概率增加了5.74%。这一效应立即出现,仅针对黑人驾驶员,持续至集会后最多60天,且无法由驾驶行为的变化加以解释。在基线种族偏见估计值更高的执法人员中,以及在当代种族怨恨指标得分更高的地区、吉姆·克劳时代经历过更多种族暴力的地区,和曾经蓄奴的县,该效应显著更大。无论是明确还是隐晦地提及种族议题,特朗普演讲中的此类内容都会加剧其集会对种族偏见估计值较高的执法人员产生的影响。

Abstract

Abstract Can political rallies affect the behavior of law enforcement officers toward racial minorities? Using data from 35 million traffic stops, we show that the probability that a stopped driver is Black increases by 5.74% after a Trump rally during his 2015–2016 campaign. The effect is immediate, specific to Black drivers, lasts for up to 60 days after the rally, and is not justified by changes in driver behavior. The effects are significantly larger among law enforcement officers whose estimated racial bias is higher at baseline, in areas that score higher on present-day measures of racial resentment, those that experienced more racial violence during the Jim Crow era, and in former slave-holding counties. Mentions of racial issues in Trump speeches, whether explicit or implicit, exacerbate the effect of a Trump rally among officers with higher estimated racial bias.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →