← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

新政与新爱国者:20世纪30年代的政府支出如何在第二次世界大战期间增强爱国主义

New Deal, New Patriots: How 1930s Government Spending Boosted Patriotism During World War II
Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2022 · Bruno Caprettini、Hans‐Joachim Voth

中文摘要

我们揭示了爱国主义与公共品供给之间一种重要的互补关系。1933年以后,新政推动美国联邦政府的职能空前扩张。社会支出的受益者在第二次世界大战期间表现出显著更强的爱国主义:他们购买了更多战争债券,更积极地参与志愿服务,并且在从军期间获得了更多勋章。这种模式是新出现的——第一次世界大战期间的志愿参军并未呈现出相同的爱国主义地理分布。我们将兵役记录与1940年人口普查数据进行匹配,表明这一模式在个体层面同样成立。利用地理差异,我们采用两个工具变量来说明该效应具有因果性:干旱和国会委员会代表情况可以预测更多的新政农业支持,也可以预测战争债券购买、志愿服务和勋章获得情况。

Abstract

Abstract We demonstrate an important complementarity between patriotism and public-good provision. After 1933, the New Deal led to an unprecedented expansion of the U.S. federal government’s role. Those who benefited from social spending were markedly more patriotic during World War II: they bought more war bonds, volunteered more, and, as soldiers, won more medals. This pattern was new—World War I volunteering did not show the same geography of patriotism. We match military service records with the 1940 census to show that this pattern holds at the individual level. Using geographical variation, we exploit two instruments to suggest that the effect is causal: droughts and congressional committee representation predict more New Deal agricultural support, as well as bond buying, volunteering, and medals.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →