← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

最优长期健康保险合同:刻画、计算与福利效应

Optimal Long-Term Health Insurance Contracts: Characterization, Computation, and Welfare Effects
Review of Economic Studies · 2023 · Soheil Ghili、Ben Handel、Igal Hendel、Michael D. Whinston

中文摘要

再分类风险是健康保险中的一个主要问题:合同期限通常仅为1年,但健康冲击往往持续更长时间。尽管大多数由私人保险公司参与的医疗保障体系将短期合同与严格的定价规制相结合,以降低再分类风险,但保险公司单方承诺的长期合同具有显著潜力,能够在不产生价格规制所带来的逆向选择等负面副作用的情况下,降低再分类风险。我们从理论上刻画了具有单方承诺的最优长期保险合同,并沿着研究健康保险市场所必需的方向拓展了相关文献。基于这一刻画,我们提出了一种从原始参数出发计算最优合同的简便算法。我们利用犹他州所有65岁以下拥有私人保险的消费者数据,估计关键的市场基本参数。我们发现,动态合同能够非常有效地降低初次进入市场时健康状况良好的消费者所面临的再分类风险,但对进入市场时健康状况不佳的消费者无效,这表明政府有必要为进入市场前的健康风险提供保险。收入增长轨迹陡峭的个人认为前置成本高昂,因此相对更偏好《平价医疗法案》(ACA)式保险交易所。转换成本会提高动态合同的绩效,而短视则会在一定程度上削弱其绩效。

Abstract

Abstract Reclassification risk is a major concern in health insurance where contracts are typically 1 year in length but health shocks often persist for much longer. While most health systems with private insurers pair short-run contracts with substantial pricing regulations to reduce reclassification risk, long-term contracts with one-sided insurer commitment have significant potential to reduce reclassification risk without the negative side effects of price regulation, such as adverse selection. We theoretically characterize optimal long-term insurance contracts with one-sided commitment, extending the literature in directions necessary for studying health insurance markets. We leverage this characterization to provide a simple algorithm for computing optimal contracts from primitives. We estimate key market fundamentals using data on all under-65 privately insured consumers in Utah. We find that dynamic contracts are very effective at reducing reclassification risk for consumers who arrive at the market in good health, but they are ineffective for consumers who come to the market in bad health, demonstrating that there is a role for the government insurance of pre-market health risks. Individuals with steeply rising income profiles find front-loading costly, and thus relatively prefer ACA-type exchanges. Switching costs enhance, while myopia moderately compromises, the performance of dynamic contracts.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →