← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

促进警务改革:执法记录仪、警察涉入的杀人事件与执法结果

Facilitating police reform: Body cameras, police-involved homicides, and law enforcement outcomes
Journal of Public Economics · 2025 · Tae-Ho Kim

中文摘要

执法记录仪(BWC)已成为恢复警察合法性的关键改革措施。然而,关于执法记录仪在何种条件下能够减少武力使用并影响更广泛的机构整体结果,现有证据仍然有限。本文采用准实验事件研究设计,分析美国593个警察机构的数据,以估计采用执法记录仪的影响。研究发现,警察涉入的杀人事件减少具有异质性——这一效应集中在此类事件先前发生水平较高的地区以及对设备启用要求更严格的机构,而在事件发生水平较低的地区或政策较宽松的机构中未发现可测量的变化。本研究还首次提供了关于机构整体结果的证据,发现总体逮捕率或犯罪率不存在显著的权衡。这些发现有助于理解执法记录仪在何种情况下最有可能增强警察问责与执法绩效。

Abstract

Body-worn cameras (BWCs) have emerged as a crucial reform to restore police legitimacy. However, there remains limited evidence on the conditions under which BWCs reduce use of force and affect broader agency-wide outcomes. Using a quasi-experimental event study design, I analyze data from 593 U.S. police agencies to estimate the effects of BWC adoption. I find that reductions in police-involved homicides are heterogeneous—concentrated in regions with higher prior levels of such incidents and in agencies with stricter activation requirements, with no measurable change in low-incident regions or agencies with weaker policies. This study also provides the first evidence on agency-wide outcomes, finding no significant trade-offs in overall arrest or crime rates. These findings offer insight into when BWCs are most likely to enhance police accountability and performance.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →