Journal of Public Economics · 2025 · Duha T. Altindag、Samuel Cole、Elif S. Filiz
中文摘要
既有研究表明,当学生的种族与其教师相匹配、且年龄显著小于教师时,其学业表现会有所改善。本研究考察这种种族匹配效应是否同样适用于年龄大于其授课教师的学生。我们使用一所拥有大量非传统年龄学生的高校的行政数据,并聚焦于必修课程以排除策略性选择授课教师的可能性,发现种族匹配与较年轻学生的成绩提升相关,但对于与教授年龄相仿或年长的学生则不然。尽管数据集以白人族裔的师生配对为主,额外的分析显示少数族裔群体中也呈现类似模式,但在统计功效上存在一定局限。效应最强的是非传统年龄的黑人学生。我们的发现表明,种族匹配教师对较年轻学生的益处可能由榜样渠道驱动,即年长的教授通过指导与激励对较年轻学生的学业表现产生积极影响。
Abstract
Past research shows that students’ educational outcomes improve when their race matches their teachers’ and they are significantly younger than their teachers. This study examines whether these racial congruence effects apply to students who are older than their instructors. Using administrative data from a university with a significant population of non-traditional-aged students and focusing on required classes to eliminate strategic instructor choice possibility, we find that race matches are associated with improved grades for younger students but not for those of similar age or older relative to their professors. While the dataset predominantly features White student–teacher pairs, additional analyses yield similar patterns for minorities with some limitations for statistical power. The most potent effects are observed for non-traditional-aged Black students. Our findings suggest that the benefits of race-matched instructors for younger students may be driven by the role model channel, wherein older professors positively influence younger students’ academic performance through mentoring and motivation.