← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

零利率下限下的减税是否具有紧缩效应?来自百年数据的证据

Are Tax Cuts Contractionary at the Zero Lower Bound? Evidence from a Century of Data
Journal of Political Economy · 2025 · James Cloyne、Nicholas Dimsdale、Patrick Hürtgen

中文摘要

流行的新凯恩斯主义宏观经济模型预测,当货币政策受零利率下限(ZLB)约束时,削减各类扭曲性税收会产生紧缩效应。我们利用英国长期历史数据检验这一假说。基于一套新的、涵盖1918年至2020年且通过叙事法识别税收变动的长期数据集,我们表明,无论在低利率环境还是较为正常的时期,减税都具有扩张效应。我们未发现零利率下限下存在通货紧缩螺旋的证据。因此,当货币政策受到约束时,减税仍可能是刺激经济活动的有用工具。

Abstract

Popular New Keynesian macroeconomic models predict that cuts in various types of distortionary taxes are contractionary when monetary policy is constrained at the zero lower bound (ZLB). We turn to a long span of history in the United Kingdom to test this hypothesis. Using a new long-run dataset of narrative-identified tax changes from 1918 to 2020, we show that tax cuts are expansionary in both low-interest-rate environments and more normal times. We do not find evidence of a deflationary spiral at the ZLB. Tax cuts may therefore still be a useful tool to stimulate economic activity when monetary policy is constrained.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →