← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

抵制教育

Resisting Education
Journal of the European Economic Association · 2024 · Jean‐Paul Carvalho、Mark Koyama、Cole Williams

中文摘要

教育机构不仅积累人力资本,也塑造文化。我们提出一个文化动态模型,其中的文化动态源于教育体系中的文化传递。文化上被边缘化的群体会在经济上处于不利地位,并表现出各种形式的教育抵制。第一,个人可能会辍学,以避开教育中的文化内容。第二,个人可能会投资于其他形式的社会化,以屏蔽教育中的文化内容。最后,文化共同体可能会通过动员参与改变课程或创办自己的学校,集体抵制主流教育。我们表明,对教育的抵制可能使政策制定者无法从人口中消除另类文化特征。事实上,政策制定者可能不得不弱化教育中的文化内容,否则将面临反弹,导致另类文化特征进一步传播。我们的分析统一了日益增多的关于文化政策效应的实证研究,并就社会化机构对文化动态的影响提出了新的预测。

Abstract

Abstract Educational institutions not only build human capital; they also shape culture. We present a model of cultural dynamics produced by cultural transmission through the education system. Groups that are culturally marginalized become economically disadvantaged and exhibit various forms of resistance to education. First, individuals may drop out of education to avoid its cultural content. Second, individuals may invest in other forms of socialization to tune out the cultural content of education. Finally, cultural communities may collectively resist mainstream education by turning out to change curricula or establish their own schools. We show that resistance to education can make it impossible for a policymaker to eliminate alternative cultural traits from the population. In fact, a policymaker may have to moderate the cultural content of education or else face a backlash which increases the spread of alternative cultural traits. Our analysis unifies a growing body of empirical work on the effects of cultural policies and makes new predictions regarding the effect of socializing institutions on cultural dynamics.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →