← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

实证歧视研究的建构主义视角

A Constructivist Perspective on Empirical Discrimination Research
Journal of Economic Literature · 2023 · Evan K. Rose

中文摘要

当代学者将种族视为一种建构的社会范畴,而非生物学事实。然而,大多数实证歧视研究对种族的处理,与数据中通常观察到的其他个体特征并无二致。本文转而考察采取建构主义视角的意涵。我构建了一个简单模型,其中行为人利用可观察的特征来解读种族社会类别的归属并做出决策。歧视是基于感知的社会身份采取行动的结果。该模型强调,需要测量种族“第一阶段”——个体之间的社会身份对比——而非依赖数据中编码的种族,并在基于种族的统计歧视与直接统计歧视之间做出了新颖的区分。我利用工资、言语模式和肤色的数据阐释了一些意涵,并以基于建构主义模型的未来研究策略作为结论。

Abstract

Contemporary scholars view race as a constructed social category, not a biological fact. Yet most empirical discrimination research treats race no differently than other individual characteristics typically observed in data. This article considers the implications of adopting a constructivist perspective instead. I develop a simple model where agents use observable characteristics to both interpret membership in racial social categories and make decisions. Discrimination is the result of acting based on perceived social identity. The model highlights the need to measure the racial “first stage”—the social identity contrast between individuals—instead of relying on race as coded in data, and draws a novel distinction between race-based and direct statistical discrimination. I illustrate some implications using data on wages, speech patterns, and skin color and conclude with strategies for future research that build on the constructivist model. (JEL J15, J31, J71, K38)
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →