← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

移民与再分配支持:来自欧洲的启示

Immigration and Support for Redistribution: Lessons from Europe
Journal of Economic Literature · 2023 · Charlotte Cavaillé、Karine Van der Straeten

中文摘要

研究表明,对跨种族再分配政策的反对影响了美国福利国家的发展。西欧是否也存在类似的动态机制?许多学者认为答案是肯定的。与此相反,我们认为,研究者对日益多元化的欧洲国家中再分配政治经济学的理解尚不充分,无法就此问题得出结论。首先,现有证据与这一研究领域中普遍存在的假设并不一致,即人们普遍不愿与文化、族裔和种族背景不同者分享资源。其次,美国与欧洲之间重要的历史和制度差异,使得美国经验无法直接移用于欧洲情形。我们讨论了未来最具前景的研究方向。(JEL D64、H23、J15、J68、K37、Z13)

Abstract

Research shows that opposition to policies that redistribute across racial divides has affected the development of the American welfare state. Are similar dynamics at play in Western Europe? For many scholars, the answer is yes. In contrast, we argue that researchers’ understanding of the political economy of redistribution in diversifying European countries is too incomplete to reach a conclusion on this issue. First, existing evidence is inconsistent with the assumption—ubiquitous in this line of research—of a universal distaste for sharing resources with people who are culturally, ethnically, and racially different. Second, important historical and institutional differences between the United States and Europe preclude any straightforward transposition of the American experience to the European case. We discuss what we see as the most promising lines of inquiry going forward. (JEL D64, H23, J15, J68, K37, Z13)
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →