O Brother, Where Start Thou? Sibling Spillovers on College and Major Choice in Four Countries
Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2021 · Adam Altmejd、Andrés Barrios-Fernández、Marin Drlje、Joshua Goodman、Michael Hurwitz、Dejan Kovač
中文摘要
家庭和社会网络被广泛认为会影响重要的人生决策,但对这些效应进行因果识别是出了名的困难。我们利用智利、克罗地亚、瑞典和美国的数据,研究不同国家背景下大学和专业选择中的家庭内部溢出效应。借助只直接影响年长手足而非年幼手足大学选项的大学特定录取门槛,我们表明,在这四个国家中,都有相当一部分年幼手足追随年长手足,进入同一所大学或选择相同的大学—专业组合。无论年长手足实际选择的选项与反事实选项之间的质量差异是大、是小,甚至为负,年幼手足都会追随他们。然而,如果年长手足从大学退学,这种溢出效应便会消失,这表明年长手足的大学经历十分重要。手足在如此多样的情境下都能影响重要的人力资本投资决策,这说明我们的发现并非特定制度细节的产物,而是对人类行为一种更具普遍性的描述。亲近同伴的高等教育路径之间的因果联系,或许可以部分解释社会群体之间大学入学不平等的持续存在;这也表明,改善大学入学机会的干预措施可能具有乘数效应。
Abstract
Abstract Family and social networks are widely believed to influence important life decisions, but causal identification of those effects is notoriously challenging. Using data from Chile, Croatia, Sweden, and the United States, we study within-family spillovers in college and major choice across a variety of national contexts. Exploiting college-specific admissions thresholds that directly affect older but not younger siblings’ college options, we show that in all four countries a meaningful portion of younger siblings follow their older sibling to the same college or college-major combination. Older siblings are followed regardless of whether their target and counterfactual options have large, small, or even negative differences in quality. Spillover effects disappear, however, if the older sibling drops out of college, suggesting that older siblings’ college experiences matter. That siblings influence important human capital investment decisions across such varied contexts suggests that our findings are not an artifact of particular institutional detail but a more generalizable description of human behavior. Causal links between the postsecondary paths of close peers may partly explain persistent college enrollment inequalities between social groups, and this suggests that interventions to improve college access may have multiplier effects.