Does Integration Change Gender Attitudes? The Effect of Randomly Assigning Women to Traditionally Male Teams
Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2021 · Gordon B. Dahl、Andreas Kotsadam、Dan‐Olof Rooth
中文摘要
我们考察在传统男性主导的环境中整合男性与女性,能否改变男性对于混合性别生产率、性别角色以及性别认同的态度。我们的情境是挪威的军队,在新兵训练营期间,我们将女性新兵随机分配至部分而非其他班排。我们发现,与女性共同生活和工作八周会使男性形成更平等的态度。认为混合性别团队表现等同或优于同性团队的男性比例提高了14个百分点,认为家务应由双方平等分担的男性增加了8个百分点,不完全否认女性特质的男性增加了14个百分点。此外,处于混合性别团队的男性在新兵训练营结束后更倾向于立即选择女性占比较高的军事职业。然而,这些效应在处理停止后并未持续。在六个月的跟踪调查中,受处理男性的态度趋同于控制组,且在服役结束后,对于选择女性占比较高的学习领域、职业或工作场所,并无长期效应。与许多政策制定者的预测相反,我们并未发现在班排中整合女性会损害男性新兵的表现或对服役的满意度,无论在新兵训练营期间还是其后的军事分配中均是如此。这些发现提供了证据,表明即使在性别高度倾斜的环境中,性别刻板印象也是可塑的,并可通过整合异性成员来改变。但它们也表明,若缺乏持续的密集接触,效应不太可能持久。
Abstract
Abstract We examine whether integrating men and women in a traditionally male-dominated environment can change men's attitudes about mixed-gender productivity, gender roles, and gender identity. Our context is the military in Norway, where we randomly assigned female recruits to some squads but not others during boot camp. We find that living and working with women for eight weeks causes men to have more egalitarian attitudes. There is a 14 percentage point higher fraction of men who think mixed-gender teams perform as well or better than same-gender teams, an 8 percentage point increase in men who think household work should be shared equally, and a 14 percentage point increase in men who do not completely disavow feminine traits. Moreover, men in mixed-gender teams are more likely to choose military occupations immediately after boot camp that have a higher fraction of women in them. But these effects do not persist once treatment stops. Treated men’s attitudes converge to those of the controls in a six-month follow-up survey, and there is no long-term effect on choosing fields of study, occupations, or workplaces with a higher fraction of women after military service ends. Contrary to the predictions of many policy makers, we do not find that integrating women into squads hurt male recruits’ performance or satisfaction with service, either during boot camp or their subsequent military assignment. These findings provide evidence that even in a highly gender-skewed environment, gender stereotypes are malleable and can be altered by integrating members of the opposite sex. But they also suggest that without continuing intensive exposure, effects are unlikely to persist.