← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

建设有韧性的卫生系统:来自塞拉利昂和2014年埃博拉疫情的实验证据*

Building Resilient Health Systems: Experimental Evidence from Sierra Leone and The 2014 Ebola Outbreak*
Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2020 · Darin Christensen、Oeindrila Dube、Johannes Haushofer、Bilal Siddiqi、Maarten Voors

中文摘要

人们认为,对卫生系统质量的质疑及其导致的服务利用不足,是发展中国家死亡率居高不下的重要原因。在疫情期间,当人们需要决定是否配合应对工作及一线医务人员时,其对医疗卫生服务质量的感知可能尤为关键。提高人们感知到的医疗服务质量能否促进社区健康,并最终帮助遏制疫情?我们利用在塞拉利昂开展的一项田野实验,在2014年西非埃博拉危机的背景下回答这一问题。疫情暴发前两年,我们将两项干预随机分配给政府运营的卫生诊所:一项侧重于社区监督,另一项向诊所工作人员颁发非经济性奖励。在埃博拉危机发生之前,两项干预均提高了诊所利用率和患者满意度。社区监督还额外改善了儿童健康,使五岁以下儿童死亡人数减少了38%。此后在危机期间,这些干预还使埃博拉病例报告数增加了62%,且社区监督显著减少了埃博拉相关死亡。有关机制的证据表明,两项干预均提高了人们感知到的医疗服务质量,从而鼓励患者报告埃博拉症状并接受医疗照护。社区监督下健康结果的改善表明,这些变化在一定程度上反映了实际提供的医疗服务的内在质量有所提升。总体而言,我们的结果表明,促进问责不仅能够在常态时期改善卫生系统,还能增强其应对突发危机的韧性。

Abstract

Abstract Skepticism about the quality of health systems and their consequent underuse are thought to contribute to high rates of mortality in the developing world. The perceived quality of health services may be especially critical during epidemics, when people choose whether to cooperate with response efforts and frontline health workers. Can improving the perceived quality of health care promote community health and ultimately help to contain epidemics? We leverage a field experiment in Sierra Leone to answer this question in the context of the 2014 West African Ebola crisis. Two years before the outbreak, we randomly assigned two interventions to government-run health clinics—one focused on community monitoring, and the other conferred nonfinancial awards to clinic staff. Prior to the Ebola crisis, both interventions increased clinic utilization and patient satisfaction. Community monitoring additionally improved child health, leading to 38% fewer deaths of children under age five. Later, during the crisis, the interventions also increased reporting of Ebola cases by 62%, and community monitoring significantly reduced Ebola-related deaths. Evidence on mechanisms suggests that both interventions improved the perceived quality of health care, encouraging patients to report Ebola symptoms and receive medical care. Improvements in health outcomes under community monitoring suggest that these changes partly reflect a rise in the underlying quality of administered care. Overall, our results indicate that promoting accountability not only has the power to improve health systems during normal times, but can also make them more resilient to emergent crises.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →