Mass Political Information on Social Media: Facebook Ads, Electorate Saturation, and Electoral Accountability in Mexico
Journal of the European Economic Association · 2024 · José Ramón Enríquez、Horacio Larreguy、John Marshall、Alberto Simpser
中文摘要
社交媒体几乎能够同时、快速且低成本地触达大量受众,这一能力具有促进选举问责的潜力。除了增加对信息的直接接触外,以相当大比例选民为目标的高饱和度宣传活动,还可能诱发或放大选民之间的信息扩散、说服或协调。我们在市镇层面随机分配广告覆盖饱和度,评估了2018年非党派Facebook广告的选举影响——这些广告向数百万墨西哥公民通报了市政支出违规情况。在被直接定向投放的选区中,零/可忽略不计违规行为的现任政党,其得票率提高了6—7个百分点。当广告针对80%而非20%的市镇选民时,这种直接效应,以及处理市镇内未被定向选区的间接效应,均显著更大。高饱和度宣传活动的放大效应,是由社会联系更紧密的市镇内的公民所驱动的,而非政客或媒体机构的反应所致。这些发现表明,大众媒体如何能够激发社会互动,从而促进政治问责。
Abstract
Abstract Social media’s capacity to quickly and inexpensively reach large audiences almost simultaneously has the potential to promote electoral accountability. Beyond increasing direct exposure to information, high saturation campaigns—which target substantial fractions of an electorate—may induce or amplify information diffusion, persuasion, or coordination between voters. Randomizing saturation across municipalities, we evaluate the electoral impact of non-partisan Facebook ads informing millions of Mexican citizens of municipal expenditure irregularities in 2018. The vote shares of incumbent parties that engaged in zero/negligible irregularities increased by 6–7 percentage points in directly-targeted electoral precincts. This direct effect, but also the indirect effect in untargeted precincts within treated municipalities, were significantly greater where ads targeted 80%—rather than 20%—of the municipal electorate. The amplifying effects of high saturation campaigns are driven by citizens within more socially-connected municipalities, rather than responses by politicians or media outlets. These findings demonstrate how mass media can ignite social interactions to promote political accountability.