← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

公共部门的粉饰行为:来自中国义务教育普及计划的证据

Window dressing in the public sector: Evidence from China’s compulsory education promotion program
Journal of Public Economics · 2023 · Hanming Fang、Chang Liu、Li‐An Zhou

中文摘要

我们分析了20世纪90年代中国地方政府的粉饰行为。当时,地方政府被要求完成中央政府规定的义务教育目标,县级官员若未能完成这些目标,将面临严重的负面职业后果。我们发现,随着预先规定的检查期临近,县级教育支出逐步增加,但在检查结束后大幅下降。这一现象被解释为县级政府粉饰行为的证据。进一步分析表明,任期较长、因而更接近晋升考核的地方官员往往采取更为激进的粉饰行为。粉饰行为给学龄青少年带来了实际后果:受到地方政府粉饰行为影响的青少年,其初中毕业率明显更低,日后的劳动力市场表现也更差。

Abstract

We analyze the window-dressing behavior of China’s local governments throughout the 1990s, when they were required to fulfill compulsory education targets imposed by the central government. County officials faced severe negative career consequences if they failed to fulfill these targets. We found that county-level education expenditures increased progressively as the pre-specified inspection period drew near but decreased dramatically after the inspection. This phenomenon was interpreted as evidence of the window-dressing behavior of county governments. Further analysis suggests that local officials with longer tenure and who were thus closer to promotion evaluations tended to engage in more aggressively window-dressing. Window-dressing behavior generates real consequences for school-age teenagers: those exposed to local governments’ window-dressing behavior recorded considerably lower junior high school graduation rates and poorer labor market outcomes later in life.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →