← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

警察使用武力的同伴效应

Peer Effects in Police Use of Force
American Economic Journal: Economic Policy · 2023 · Justin Holz、Roman Rivera、Bocar Ba

中文摘要

我们利用一个由通过随机抽签一同就读警察学院的警官构成的网络,研究警官执勤受伤与其同伴使用武力之间的联系。执勤受伤会使其同伴警官在随后一周内使用武力的概率提高7%。这些警官也更有可能致伤嫌疑人,并收到有关忽视受害者和侵犯宪法权利的投诉。该效应集中在事件发生后的一个狭窄时间窗口内,且并未伴随警官自身受伤风险的显著降低。综合来看,这些发现表明,驱动这些效应的是情绪反应,而非社会学习。

Abstract

We study the link between police officers’ on-duty injuries and their peers’ force use using a network of officers who attended the police academy together through a random lottery. On-duty injuries increase the probability of officers using force by 7 percent in the subsequent week. Officers are also more likely to injure suspects and receive complaints about neglecting victims and violating constitutional rights. The effect is concentrated in a narrow time window following the event and is not associated with significantly lower injury risk to the officer. Together, these findings suggest that emotional responses drive the effects rather than social learning. (JEL H76, J28, K42)
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →