The protective role of index insurance in the experience of violent conflict: Evidence from Ethiopia
Journal of Development Economics · 2024 · Tekalign Gutu Sakketa、Daniel Maggio、John G. McPeak
中文摘要
干旱是造成东非牧民群体牲畜死亡和冲突的主要原因之一。为增强这些群体的气候韧性,基于指数的牲畜保险(IBLI)产品日益普及。此类产品使牧民能够对冲气候风险,并且通常利用遥感数据触发保险赔款,从而缓解标准保险产品所伴随的道德风险问题。我们研究了埃塞俄比亚南部的一个此类项目如何与降水不足造成的冲突风险相互作用。首先,我们发现,降雨量遭受1毫米的负向冲击与冲突风险增加0.32—0.43个百分点相关。这表明,降雨量减少一个标准差可能使家庭面临的冲突风险最多增至原来的两倍。随后,我们利用一项随机鼓励实验发现,参与IBLI可使家庭面临的冲突风险最多降低4.9个百分点,而且降雨状况越差,IBLI的保护效应越强。我们的次要分析表明,迁移压力降低和收入多样化是驱动上述结果的机制。研究结果意味着,在家庭同时面临气候风险与冲突风险且两类风险本身可能相互作用的复杂风险地区,指数保险项目可以发挥保护作用。
Abstract
Droughts are among the leading causes of livestock mortality and conflict among pastoralist populations in East Africa. To foster climate resiliency in these populations, Index Based Livestock Insurance (IBLI) products have become popular. These products, which allow herders to hedge climate risk , often utilize remote-sensed data to trigger indemnity payouts, thus ameliorating moral hazard issues associated with standard insurance products. We study how one such program in southern Ethiopia interacts with conflict risk created by insufficient precipitation. First, we show that a 1 mm negative shock to rainfall is associated with an increase of 0.32–0.43 percentage points of conflict risk, suggesting a one standard deviation decrease in rainfall has the potential to as much as double conflict risk faced by households. By leveraging a randomized encouragement experiment, we then show that participation in IBLI decreases the conflict risk that households face by as much as 4.9 percentage points and that the protective effect of IBLI grows when rainfall is poor. Our secondary analysis suggests that reduced migratory pressure and income diversification drive our results. Our results imply that index insurance programs can act as a protective factor in areas with complex risk profiles, where households are exposed to both climatic and conflict risks, which themselves may interact.