← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

多元社会中的国家建构

State Building in a Diverse Society
Review of Economic Studies · 2024 · Ruth Carlitz、Ameet Morjaria、Joris Mueller、Philip Osafo-Kwaako

中文摘要

多样性可能对国家建构与发展构成根本性挑战。坦桑尼亚的乌贾马政策——后殖民时期非洲规模最大的国家建构实验之一——通过将多元人口重新安置到规划村庄中来应对这些挑战,村中儿童接受政治教育。我们结合不同地区和年龄群体在乌贾马政策暴露程度上的差异,识别该政策的长期影响。对当代调查数据的分析显示,该政策对国家认同与感知到的国家合法性具有持续的正向影响。我们倾向的解释是,教育内容的变化驱动了这些结果,这一解释得到了考虑替代假说的证据支持。我们的研究发现还揭示了国家建构所伴随的权衡:尽管该政策有助于确立新国家作为合法中央权威的地位,但乌贾马政策暴露降低了民众对民主问责的诉求,且并未提高普遍性的族际信任。

Abstract

Abstract Diversity can pose fundamental challenges to state building and development. The Tanzanian Ujamaa policy—one of post-colonial Africa’s largest state-building experiments—addressed these challenges by resettling a diverse population in planned villages, where children received political education. We combine differences in exposure to Ujamaa across space and age to identify long-term impacts of the policy. Analysis of contemporary surveys shows persistent, positive effects on national identity and perceived state legitimacy. Our preferred interpretation, supported by evidence that considers alternative hypotheses, is that changes to educational content drive our results. Our findings also point to trade-offs associated with state building: while the policy contributed to establishing the new state as a legitimate central authority, exposure to Ujamaa lowered demands for democratic accountability and did not increase generalized inter-ethnic trust.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →