Econometrica · 2021 · Alberto Alesina、Sebastian Hohmann、Stelios Michalopoulos、Elias Papaioannou
中文摘要
我们利用人口普查数据,考察了非洲各国独立以来受教育程度的代际流动性(IM)。首先,我们绘制了涵盖27个国家、逾2800个地区的代际流动性地图,记录了广泛的跨国异质性,尤其是国内异质性。惯性的作用很大:老一代识字率的差异解释了所观察到的代际流动性空间差异的约一半。城乡差距很大。尽管某些国家的性别差距较为突出,但没有证据表明代际流动性存在系统性的性别差距。其次,我们刻画了代际流动性的地理特征,发现殖民时期对铁路和基督教传教机构的投资,以及邻近首都和海岸线的程度,是关联最强的因素。第三,我们探究代际流动性的地区差异究竟反映了空间分选,还是地区本身的独立作用。为区分二者,我们聚焦于家庭在其年幼时迁移的儿童。通过比较兄弟姐妹、考察由流离失所冲击引发的迁移,并利用历史迁移预测迁移家庭的目的地,我们确认,尽管选择效应相当大,地区暴露效应也确实在发挥作用。在5岁之后、12岁之前,在高流动性地区每多生活一年,父母未受过教育的儿童完成小学教育的可能性就会显著提高。总体而言,证据表明,地理和历史因素为代际流动性的空间差异埋下了种子,而空间分选和地区的独立影响则使这些差异固化。
Abstract
We examine intergenerational mobility (IM) in educational attainment in Africa since independence using census data. First, we map IM across 27 countries and more than 2,800 regions, documenting wide cross-country and especially within-country heterogeneity. Inertia looms large as differences in the literacy of the old generation explain about half of the observed spatial disparities in IM. The rural-urban divide is substantial. Though conspicuous in some countries, there is no evidence of systematic gender gaps in IM. Second, we characterize the geography of IM, finding that colonial investments in railroads and Christian missions, as well as proximity to capitals and the coastline are the strongest correlates. Third, we ask whether the regional differences in mobility reflect spatial sorting or their independent role. To isolate the two, we focus on children whose families moved when they were young. Comparing siblings, looking at moves triggered by displacement shocks, and using historical migrations to predict moving-families' destinations, we establish that, while selection is considerable, regional exposure effects are at play. An extra year spent in a high-mobility region before the age of 12 (and after 5) significantly raises the likelihood for children of uneducated parents to complete primary school. Overall, the evidence suggests that geographic and historical factors laid the seeds for spatial disparities in IM that are cemented by sorting and the independent impact of regions.