← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

司法颠覆:政治权力对法院裁决结果的影响

Judicial subversion: The effects of political power on court outcomes
Journal of Public Economics · 2022 · Guilherme Lambais、Henrik Sigstad

中文摘要

掌权的政治人物在法庭上是否会受到更宽大的对待?我们表明,被指控存在不当行为的巴西市长候选人若以微弱优势赢得选举,其被定罪的可能性会降低65%。政治人物对法官的职业生涯不起直接作用,这表明形式上的独立性并不能使司法机构完全免受政治影响。该效应由法官人数较少的地区以及职业不稳定性较高的法官所驱动。

Abstract

Are politicians in power treated more leniently in court? We show that Brazilian mayoral candidates charged with misconduct are 65 percent less likely to be convicted if they narrowly win the election. Politicians play no direct role in the judges’ careers, suggesting that formal independence does not completely insulate the judiciary from political influence. The effect is driven by districts with few judges and by judges with higher career instability.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →