← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

基于种族特征的执法检验中的内生驾驶行为

Endogenous Driving Behavior in Tests of Racial Profiling
Journal of Human Resources · 2023 · Jesse Kalinowski、Matthew B. Ross、Stephen L. Ross

中文摘要

非裔美国驾驶员可能会因警方加强审查而调整自身行为,从而使依赖受处理个体中少数族裔占比的歧视检验(例如针对交通拦截的检验)产生偏误。我们采用“黑暗面纱”策略,考察交通事故死亡和超速违章情况,以识别此类行为反应。在白天,种族特征更容易被观察到,非裔美国驾驶员发生致命机动车事故的可能性较低。在马萨诸塞州和田纳西州,我们发现,被拦截的非裔美国驾驶员在白天的驾驶速度较慢。校准结果表明,这种行为会在传统的歧视检验中造成实质性偏误。

Abstract

Abstract African-American motorists may adjust their behavior in response to increased scrutiny by police biasing tests of discrimination that rely on the share of treated individuals who are minority, such as for traffic stops. We use the “Veil of Darkness” strategy to examine traffic fatalities and speeding infractions to detect such behavioral responses. In daylight, when race is more easily observable, African-American motorists are less likely to have fatal motor vehicle accidents. In Massachusetts and Tennessee, we find that stopped African-Americans motorists drove at slower speeds in daylight. Calibrations indicate that this behavior creates substantial bias in conventional tests of discrimination.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →