← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

作为选择的贩卖人口?来自尼日利亚的证据

Trafficking as choice? Evidence from Nigeria
Journal of Development Economics · 2026 · [{"name": "Tamara Bogatzki", "affiliation": ["WZB Berlin Social Science Center", "Christian-Albrechts-Universität zu Kiel"]}, {"name": "Daniel Meierrieks", "affiliation": ["WZB Berlin Social Science Center"]}]

中文摘要

关于人口贩运的论述常将移民描绘为受欺骗的受害者, 而另一类观点则将贩运视为一种受约束的迁移策略。我们利用来自尼日利亚埃多州(Edo State)两期横截面调查(2021年和2023年)的原创数据, 对这一争论作出贡献, 样本覆盖2700多名受访者。相当大比例的受访者表示, 尽管意识到强迫劳动的风险, 仍愿意通过贩运者迁移。一项列表实验提供了提示性证据, 表明对贩运的认可存在低报, 尤其是在女性中, 这很可能反映了围绕性工作的污名。我们通过一个「抱负—能力」框架考察贩运认可的决定因素。通过贩运者迁移的意愿在迁移抱负强烈但能力有限的个体中最高; 相比之下, 接触反贩运宣传活动的影响甚微。受访者总体上充分了解与贩运相关的潜在风险与回报, 并未表现出动机性推理(motivated reasoning)等认知偏差。总体而言, 我们的发现表明, 贩运并非主要由无知驱动, 而是反映了一种受有限的合法迁移选项和结构性障碍所塑造的受约束选择。• 在尼日利亚埃多州一项具有代表性的调查中, 尽管存在强迫劳动风险, 仍有四分之一的受访者会考虑通过贩运方式实现迁移。• 列表实验揭示了存在性别差异的低报。• 高抱负与低能力预测了对贩运的认可。• 会诉诸贩运的潜在移民对风险和收入持有合理预期, 没有证据表明存在动机性推理或选择性回忆。• 宣传活动影响有限; 需要结构性改革。

Abstract

The discourse on human trafficking often depicts migrants as deceived victims, while alternative accounts view trafficking as a constrained migration strategy. We contribute to this debate using original survey data from two cross-sectional waves (2021 and 2023) covering more than 2700 respondents in Edo State, Nigeria. A substantial share of respondents reports a willingness to migrate via traffickers despite awareness of the risks of forced labor. A list experiment provides suggestive evidence of underreporting of trafficking approval, particularly among women, likely reflecting stigma surrounding sex work. We examine the determinants of trafficking approval through an aspirations–capabilities framework. Willingness to migrate via traffickers is highest among individuals with strong migration aspirations but limited capabilities. In contrast, exposure to anti-trafficking campaigns has little effect. Respondents are generally well-informed about the potential risks and returns associated with trafficking and do not exhibit cognitive biases such as motivated reasoning. Overall, our findings suggest that trafficking is not primarily driven by ignorance, but instead reflects a constrained choice shaped by limited legal migration options and structural barriers. • 1 in 4 would consider trafficking for migration despite forced labor risks in a representative survey in Edo State, Nigeria. • List experiment reveals gendered underreporting. • High aspirations and low capabilities predict trafficking approval. • Prospective migrants who would resort to trafficking hold reasonable risk and income expectations, with no evidence of motivated reasoning or selective recall. • Awareness campaigns show limited impact; structural reform is needed.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →