← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

挽救被证伪的工具变量模型

Salvaging Falsified Instrumental Variable Models
Econometrica · 2021 · Matthew A. Masten、Alexandre Poirier

中文摘要

当研究者的基准模型被证伪时,他们应该怎么做?我们建议报告与最小非证伪模型相一致的参数集。我们将其称为证伪自适应集(FAS)。该集合推广了标准基准估计量以解释可能的证伪。重要的是,它不要求研究者选择或校准敏感性参数。在包含多个工具变量的经典线性工具变量模型中,我们证明FAS具有简单的闭式表达式,该表达式仅依赖于少数几个两阶段最小二乘(2SLS)系数。我们将结论应用于一项关于道路与贸易的实证研究。我们表明FAS如何通过总结从备选非证伪模型获得的估计值的变异,对传统的过度识别检验形成补充。

Abstract

What should researchers do when their baseline model is falsified? We recommend reporting the set of parameters that are consistent with minimally nonfalsified models. We call this thefalsification adaptive set(FAS). This set generalizes the standard baseline estimand to account for possible falsification. Importantly, it does not require the researcher to select or calibrate sensitivity parameters. In the classical linear IV model with multiple instruments, we show that the FAS has a simple closed‐form expression that only depends on a few 2SLS coefficients. We apply our results to an empirical study of roads and trade. We show how the FAS complements traditional overidentification tests by summarizing the variation in estimates obtained from alternative nonfalsified models.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →