头号女生:初中女生高分获得者与同伴学业表现
Number one girl: Female top scorers and peer academic performance in junior high schools
Journal of Development Economics · 2026 · [{"name": "Xuezheng Qin", "affiliation": ["Peking University"]}, {"name": "Yingfei Wang", "affiliation": ["Peking University"]}, {"name": "Haochen Zhang", "affiliation": ["Zhejiang University of Finance and Economics"]}]
中文摘要
在锦标赛式的教育体系中,序数学业排名的高度凸显性可能会放大顶尖学生作为榜样的影响力。本文考察中国初中班级中最高分学生的性别如何影响同班同学的学习成果。利用一项断点回归设计——即借助班级中成绩最好的女生与男生之间极小的分数差异——我们发现,在一次重要考试中由女生位居第一名,会显著提高女生后续的学业表现,而在男生中未观察到类似效应。这一性别特定效应可能通过多种渠道发挥作用:当班级第一名为女生时,其他女生表现出更高水平的自信、学业抱负和学习努力,并获得更多父母支持——而这些效应在男生中并不存在。此外,最高分学生性别的影响在学业排名较低的女生以及来自弱势家庭的女生中尤为明显。总之,本文首次为教育情境中序数排名的性别差异化外部效应提供了因果证据。
Abstract
In a tournament-style education system, the high salience of ordinal academic rankings may amplify top performers’ influence as role models. This paper investigates how the gender of the top scorer in the class affects peer students’ outcomes in Chinese junior high schools. Leveraging a regression discontinuity design that exploits minimal score differences between the top-performing female and male students in a class, we find that having a female first-ranked student in a major exam significantly improves subsequent academic performance among girls, while no comparable effects are observed among boys. This gender-specific effect potentially operates through multiple channels: when a female student ranks first in the class, other girls exhibit higher levels of self-confidence, academic aspirations, study effort, and receive more parental support—effects that are not present among boys. Furthermore, the impact of top performer gender is particularly pronounced among academically lower-ranked girls and those from disadvantaged families. In sum, this paper provides the first causal evidence of the gender-differentiated external effect of ordinal ranks in educational settings.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →