← ireadpaper · 顶刊中的公共政策研究

群体认同如何影响代议制民主中的再分配?一项实验

How does group identification affect redistribution in representative democracies? An Experiment
Journal of Public Economics · 2022 · Shaun P. Hargreaves Heap、Emma Manifold、Konstantinos Matakos、Dimitrios Xefteris

中文摘要

我们在实验室中检验了群体认同可能影响代议制民主中再分配的四种机制。对选民而言,群体认同可以产生对本群体收益的偏好、对选举本群体候选人的偏好,也可能被用于评估候选人的真诚程度。对候选人而言,认同可能影响最优竞选纲领。四种机制均有证据支持。我们的核心贡献在于将候选人的再分配政策供给与选民对再分配的需求共同纳入均衡分析。这一分析带来了一项重要的新见解:少数群体在参选候选人中获得政治代表的程度,对再分配结果具有关键影响。

Abstract

We test in the laboratory four mechanisms whereby group identification might affect redistribution in representative democracies. For voters, group identification can give rise to a preference for own-group payoffs, for electing an own-group candidate, and could be used to assess candidate-sincerity. For candidates, identity might affect the optimal campaign platform. There is evidence to support all four. Our key contribution comes from bringing the candidate supply of redistribution policies into an equilibrium analysis with voter demand for redistribution. It yields an important new insight: the extent of minority group political representation among the electoral candidates critically affects redistribution outcomes.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →