危机时期青少年的安全空间
Safe Spaces for Teenage Girls in a Time of Crisis
Journal of the European Economic Association · 2025 · [{"name": "Oriana Bandiera", "affiliation": ["London School of Economics and Political Science"]}, {"name": "Niklas Buehren", "affiliation": []}, {"name": "Markus Goldstein", "affiliation": []}, {"name": "Imran Rasul", "affiliation": ["Institute for Fiscal Studies", "University College London"]}, {"name": "Andrea Smurra", "affiliation": ["Institute for Fiscal Studies", "University College London"]}]
中文摘要
摘要 低收入国家的青春期女孩处于不利境地,其根源在于她们对自身身体的自主权有限,以及在投资自身人力资本方面面临障碍。我们以2014—2016年塞拉利昂埃博拉疫情为背景,研究这些结果在总量危机时期如何被塑造。在这一背景下,由于针对青春期女孩的性剥削和性暴力发生率高,她们长期处于不利地位。本研究围绕对疫情期间实施的一项面向年轻女性的俱乐部式干预的评估展开。我们追踪了2700名12—18岁的女孩,时间从2014年疫情前夕一直到2016年塞拉利昂被宣布无埃博拉之前。该俱乐部式干预提供了一个安全空间,女孩们可以在其中远离男性,并获得生殖健康建议、职业培训和/或小额信贷。疫情期间,所有学校均关闭。我们发现,在缺少在校时间这一保护的情况下,对照村庄的青春期女孩与男性相处的时间增多,怀孕率急剧上升,疫情后其入学率下降。安全空间的提供打断了这一因果链条:它使处理村庄的女孩能够将时间分配到远离男性的活动上,并减少非婚怀孕。这些效应在女孩预测怀孕风险最高的地方最为明显。在这些地区,该干预还提高了疫情后的复学率。为进一步厘清作用机制,我们利用了俱乐部所提供投入组合的第二层随机化。这进一步强化了如下观点:安全空间这一组成部分对于驱动青春期女孩的结果至关重要。我们的分析对于年轻女性面临性暴力情境下健康危机期间的学校关闭具有启示意义,凸显了安全空间在此类时期所能提供的保护性和持久作用。
Abstract
Abstract Adolescent girls across low-income countries face disadvantages stemming from limited agency over their bodies and barriers to investing in their human capital. We study how these outcomes are shaped in times of aggregate crisis, in the context of the 2014–2016 Ebola epidemic in Sierra Leone. This is a setting in which adolescent girls have long faced disadvantage because of a high prevalence of sexual exploitation and violence towards them. Our study is based around an evaluation of a club-based intervention for young women implemented during the epidemic. We track 2,700 girls aged 12–18 from the eve of the epidemic in 2014 to just prior to when Sierra Leone was declared Ebola free in 2016. The club-based intervention provides a safe space where girls can spend time away from men, receive advice on reproductive health, vocational training, and/or microfinance. During the epidemic all schools were closed. We show that without the protection of time in school, in control villages teenage girls spent more time with men, pregnancy rates rose sharply, and their school enrolment dropped post-epidemic. The provision of a safe space breaks this causal chain: It enables girls in treated villages to allocate time away from men and reduce out-of-wedlock pregnancies. These effects are most pronounced in places where girls face the highest predicted pregnancy risks. In such locations, the intervention also increases school re-enrolment rates post-epidemic. To further pin down mechanisms, we exploit a second layer of randomization of input bundles offered by clubs. This reinforces the idea that the safe space component is critical to driving outcomes for teenage girls. Our analysis has implications for school closures during health crisis in contexts where young women face sexual violence, highlighting the protective and lasting role safe spaces can provide in such times.
在 ireadpaper 查看全部 →